OU Libraries
OU Libraries

Ask a Librarian

Ask a Librarian - by email Ask a Librarian - by phone Ask a Librarian - in person

LIBRARY GUIDE TO Strategies for Publishing

Identifying & Selecting Journals
IDENTIFYING POTENTIAL JOURNALS
There are a number of ways to identify appropriate journals to publish your work. Here are just a few:

1) Check your manuscript’s reference list – what journals do you cite?

2) Conduct a search in PubMed on your topic – what journals have published similar studies already?

3) JANE (Journal/Author Name Estimator) - A cool tool developed at Erasmus University Medical Center with funding from the Netherlands Bioinformatics Centre. Simply copy & paste your manuscript’s abstract and JANE pulls a set of journals for you to possibly publish in.

4) Web of Science - Journal Citation Reports - Organizes journals into discipline categories and ranks them by various metrics (ie: total citations, impact factors, etc). Here's a quick help guide pdf for navigating the website.


SELECTING YOUR FIRST TARGET JOURNAL
Once you identify a set of potential journals, check each journal's website for the following:
  1. Does your manuscript fit the scope/focus of the journal?
  2. Do they publish your type of article (ie: original research, case study, case report, systematic review, etc)?
  3. Select one journal that seems to have the best fit
  4. Follow the author guidelines to the letter
  5. Submit!
  6. Wait for a response (& be sure not to submit elsewhere)
  7. Revise or submit to your second target journal
4 A's of Publishing
Predatory Publishing
The Open Access (OA) publishing model has paved the way for global scholarly communication in allowing free, unlimited access to research without the barriers of publisher paywalls. However, when selecting journals to publish in, be mindful of sham OA journals that only exist to collect fees from unwary authors. These are known as predatory publishers.

To protect yourself and your work, just remember to thoroughly check your journal before submitting an article for publication. Here are a few criteria that indicate it is a good OA journal:

> Indexed in bibliometric databases, such as PubMed, Web of Science, the Directory of Open Access Journals (DOAJ) and others. You can cross check where a journal is indexed using Ulrich's Periodical Directory.

> Journal website is comprehensive & includes the following information:
  • Editorial board information including member affiliations and emails (geographic location should be very distributed)
  • Contact information including a mailing address that goes to a legit location; contact is not just a blank web form
  • Description of article review process including peer-review
  • No promises of instant or rapid publication
  • Article processing fee is transparent and only required after acceptance of an article
For a complete list of criteria to use in assessing the quality of journals, check out the Medical Library's Checklist for Assessing Journal Authenticity pdf .

If you are a biomedical sciences faculty member, also check eligibility requirements for applying for an OA Grant from the Medical Library to cover OA journal publishing fees.
Writing the Manuscript
BEST BETS:
International Committee of Medical Journal Editors (ICMJE) Preparing a Manuscript - The ICMJE is a small working group of general medical journal editors who have developed standards in medical publishing including guidelines on how to structure and write a medical paper as well as authorship guidelines.

Medical Writing: A Guide for Clinicians, Educators, and Researchers (2011) [eBook]. Individual chapters focus on writing various types of articles including:
  •      Review articles
  •      Case reports
  •      Editorials and letters to the editor
  •      Book reviews
  •      Book chapters
  •      Reference books
  •      Research protocols
  •      Grant proposals
  •      Research reports

VIDEOS:
Elsevier Researcher Academy - A series of online learning modules on various aspects of the publishing process including research preparation, peer-review, writing for research, and more. 

University of Maryland Writing Center - Writing Tips Video Series - series of short, helpful videos on writing tips including how craft an argument, structure a paper, proofreeding, and editing. Also features time management videos such as how to carve out time for writing and limiting distractions.

ADDITIONAL RESOURCES:
Anatomy of Writing for Publication for Nurses [eBook] - Targeting nurses, but very structured and practical advice. Check out Chapters 5 - 7 on Organizing the Article, Writing Effectively, and Graphics & Tables

How to Write, Publish & Present in the Health Sciences [eBook] - published by the American College of Physicians, this book features practical advice on how to successfully publish and avoid pitfalls leading to rejection.

Writing a Research Article: Advice for Beginners (2004). Int J Qual Health Care [Journal Article]
 
Library Contact
Picture: Stephanie Swanberg

Stephanie Swanberg
Assistant Professor
swanberg@oakland.edu
248.370.3776

Authorship Guidelines
Determining authorship and author order is a significant step of the publishing process. According to the International Committee of Medical Journal Editors (ICMJE), every author should meet ALL of the following four criteria:

1) Substantial contributions to the conception, design, data collection, or data analysis
2) Drafting or revising the manuscript
3) Approving the final version to submit to a journal
4) Being accountable for the work should any questions or concerns arise

If all criteria are not met, then it is appropriate to acknowledge those individuals in the Acknowledgements section of your manuscript.

Also check the OUWB Authorship Guidelines when planning to publish!
Medical Student Journals
Medical student journals are online, peer-reviewed journals run by medical students for medical student publishing. They are a great option for pilot projects or if you are having difficulty in finding a suitable journal elsewhere.

American Medical Student Research Journal - Online, peer-reviewed, open access journal launched by medical students at Louisiana State University Health–Shreveport, International in scope and accepts articles in the categories of basic science, clinical research, case reports, humanities, and artwork.

International Journal of Medical Students - Online, peer-reviewed, open access journal accepting original articles, short communications, case reports, reviews, and a special section for letters, experiences, and interviews.

Journal of the Student National Medical Association – medical submissions are preferred (including research, abstracts, case reports, case studies, critical essays, and articles), but exceptional non-medical submissions, such as artwork, poetry, short creative writing, and photography are also considered.

Medical Student Press (MSPress) Journal - Online, peer-reviewed, open access journal accepts honors theses excerpts, scientific research papers, research essays, interviews, medical ethics essays, creative writing pieces, sound pieces, and visual art pieces.

Medical Student Research Journal Hosted at Michigan State University and accepts original articles, case studies, brief reports, reflections, or reviews.

Student BMJ: The International Medical Journal for Students
 
How to Write a Case Report
Writing a case report is very different from a traditional manuscript and does not follow the IMRAD format. There are several resources that can help you get started in structuring and writing a case report for publication.

BEST BET:
  • CARE (CAse REport) Guidelines - Great website with practical and concise tips for writing case reports developed by an international group of experts. The checklist is particularly useful for ensuring you include all the necessary information.

ADDITIONAL RESOURCES FOR WRITING CASE REPORTS:
Publishing a Case Report
There are two primary journal types when it comes to publishing case reports: 1) those journals that solely publish case reports and 2) journals that publish case reports as one of many article types. You can follow the same principles when identifying journals to publish a case report as described in the 'Publishing Basics' tab of this guide, but here are a few we recommend:

GENERAL CASE REPORT JOURNALS:
BMJ Case Reports - This is a great journal to start with when submitting a case report for publication. Both the OUWB Medical Library and Beaumont Medical Library have an institutional membership ("fellowship") so publication fees are waived.
  • If you are an OUWB affiliate (medical student, biomedical sciences faculty): contact the OUWB Medical Library at medref@oakland.edu to get the access code to waive the fee.
  • If you are a Beaumont affiliate (clinician, resident): contact the Beaumont Medical Library at ROReference@beaumont.edu to get the access code to waive the fee.

JAMA Clinical Challenge - Submit a patient case with a specific disease or condition with an accompanying clinical image.

Clinical Case Reports

International Medical Case Reports Journal

Journal of Medical Case Reports

SPECIALTY CASE REPORT JOURNALS:
Akers' article "New Journals for Publishing Medical Case Reports," published in 2016, provides a concise and informative summary table of case report journals. In addition to being a wonderful resource for identifying case report journals in various specialties, it also notes whether the journal is open access, indexed in PubMed, and has questionable publishing practices.
 
Library Contact
Picture: Stephanie Swanberg

Stephanie Swanberg
Assistant Professor
swanberg@oakland.edu
248.370.3776

Publishing Clinical Images
In addition to narrative case reports, many journals also simply publish relevant clinical images:

JAMA Clinical Challenge - Presents an actual patient case with a specific disease or condition with an accompanying clinical image.

Clinical Case Reports - welcomes clinical image submissions

Postgraduate Medical Journal (BMJ)

Journal of General Internal Medicine - allows residents and students to publish images

Student BMJ - accepts images that could be of educational value

MedPix (National Library of Medicine) - a free online repository of medical cases/images

Edit

OUWB Medical Library | 100 Library Drive, Rochester, Michigan 48309-4479 | (248) 370-3772
Hours | Location | Comments | Webmaster